Quiet Gulf beach and pale turquoise water beside a cropped cream-colored low-rise condominium and coastal greenery.

What Developers Paid per Condo on Coquina Sands' Miracle Mile

Reef Club and Harbour Club stand side by side on the bay side of Gulf Shore Boulevard North. Builder Parker Borelli described them to Gulfshore Business as having "basically the same layout and everything." Hurricane Ian's surge flooded the ground floors of both. Reef Club remodeled its first floor. At Harbour Club the first floor was left empty, and the owners sold the whole property instead.

Harbour Club sold for $17.5 million in June 2025. That works out to about $875,000 for each of its 20 co-op homes. A year before, a little over a quarter mile south, the Bahama Club sold for about $2.85 million per unit. Three years before that, the Mansion House sold for about $5.2 million per unit. All three were low-rise buildings from the 1960s or 1970s on the same road. What a developer would pay for the land under each one depended mostly on two things: whether the building sat on the sand, and how much ground came with each unit.

Five Buildings, Five Prices per Unit

The Miracle Mile is the 1.3-mile stretch of Gulf Shore Boulevard North from Doctors Pass south to Naples Beach Club, a Four Seasons Resort. It runs through The Moorings and Coquina Sands. In the table, the per-unit figures are our own division of each reported purchase price by the number of homes on the site before the sale. They are not prices any owner was quoted.

Former building

Address and side

Sold

Reported price

Original homes

Per original home

Mansion House, built 1963

1601 Gulf Shore Blvd N, Gulf

2021

$167.5 million

32

about $5.23 million

Bahama Club

1121 Gulf Shore Blvd N, Gulf

April 2024

$102.6 million

36

about $2.85 million

Executive Club, built 1969

3300 Gulf Shore Blvd N, Gulf and bay

Feb. 2023, resold Jan. 2025

$60 million, then $92.5 million

46

about $1.30 million, then about $2.01 million

Harbour Club, 1960s

1624 Gulf Shore Blvd N, bay

June 2025

$17.5 million

20

about $875,000

The fifth sale was Park Place Club, on the bay side in The Moorings. Golub & Company paid $30 million for that 1.58-acre site in May 2023, and part of the appeal was its 11 boat slips with Gulf access. It stays out of the per-unit comparison because the reports on that sale don't give the old building's unit count.

The two prices for the Executive Club show the same land rising in value. Youngquist Brothers bought it in February 2023, and by then the building had already been razed by its previous owners. Kolter Urban paid $92.5 million for the empty site in January 2025. Measured against the 46 homes that once stood there, the land gained about $700,000 per original unit in under two years.

The Gulf-Front Sites Sold for the Most

Compare the Bahama Club and Harbour Club first, because the land under each home was close to the same size. The Bahama Club had 36 homes on 2.5 acres, about 0.07 acre per home, with 220 feet of beach. Harbour Club had 20 homes on 1.41 acres, also about 0.07 acre per home, facing the Intracoastal across from Naples Beach. With similar land per home, the beachfront site sold for more than three times as much per home.

The Mansion House sits at the top of the range because it paired the beach with far more land per home. It was eight two-story co-op buildings with 32 homes on more than five acres, nearly 500 feet of beachfront, just north of Lowdermilk Park. That is roughly 0.16 acre per home, more than twice the Bahama Club's ratio. Anthony Solomon of The Ronto Group told Gulfshore Business, "There are really not too many parcels in Naples at all of that size on the beach."

What Each Site Became

The new projects show why developers paid these prices. Rosewood Residences Naples will have 42 homes on the Mansion House land, asking from $12.75 million to $45 million, and the developer has targeted completion near the end of 2026. At the Bahama Club site, Olana Naples has broken ground on 12 homes priced from $32 million, with completion scheduled for 2028. On the former Executive Club land, 3300 Gulf Shore broke ground in March 2026 on 51 homes listed from $3.7 million, with delivery targeted for summer 2028.

On the bay side, Harbour House will replace Harbour Club with 14 two-story homes in three buildings, priced from $6.5 million. Eleven optional 38-foot boat slips with direct Gulf access will be sold separately. The Naples Design Review Board approved the final plans unanimously. Borelli Construction targeted a fall groundbreaking and expects to finish in spring or summer 2028. At the former Park Place Club, Golub and Barron Collier Companies are planning 2020 Gulf Shore, an 18-home boutique project, and do not expect to break ground until spring.

Borelli explained the bayside math directly to Gulfshore Business. "Those were '60s units, so they were a little small and they had so much land that they weren't using." On the two smaller sites, the new plans hold fewer homes than the old buildings did. Olana spreads 12 homes over land that once held 36, and Harbour House puts 14 where Harbour Club had 20.

How the Buyout Prices Compare With Resale

The ordinary condo resale market sits well below these numbers. In NABOR's September 2026 report, the median closed condo price for January through September 2026 in the Naples Beach area, ZIP codes 34102, 34103 and 34108, was $1,052,500. That was down 7.3% from the same months of 2025. Closed condo sales over those nine months rose 27% to 870. In September 2026 alone, the condo median was $887,500, and condo inventory stood at 564 listings, 21.3% lower than a year earlier.

Against that median, the per-home land prices on the Gulf side of the Miracle Mile were two to five times higher. Harbour Club's roughly $875,000 per home falls below the area's nine-month median, even though it sold to a developer. These comparisons cover a broad ZIP-code median and a handful of whole-building sales, so they are rough guides rather than appraisals.

Brian Van Slyke, president of Kolter Urban, linked the selling decisions to older buildings' deferred maintenance after the Surfside collapse. He told Gulfshore Business that this "factors into the board's decision whether to make a further investment or to sell." We covered that decision in our post on condo budget season in Park Shore. On the Miracle Mile, the Bahama Club shows how it can end: after Ian, the owners of all 36 homes agreed to pursue a sale.

The Road Itself Is Next

The City of Naples is working on a long-term plan for the corridor with the citizen-formed Miracle Mile Committee. That work includes a conceptual streetscape design and a review of the utilities underneath, and the city expected to bring it to a City Council workshop this fall. For anyone comparing older buildings along Gulf Shore Boulevard North, that is one more change to the street over the next several seasons. You can follow it alongside our building updates and earlier notes from Coquina Sands.

FAQ

Where exactly is the Miracle Mile? It is the 1.3-mile stretch of Gulf Shore Boulevard North from Doctors Pass south to Naples Beach Club, through The Moorings and Coquina Sands. Residents gave it the name for how well the stretch held up through Hurricane Ian in 2022.

Which older buildings on the stretch have been torn down? Gulfshore Business lists the Bahama Club, Gulf Shore Colony Club, Harbour Club, The Mansion House and Park Place Club. Rosewood Residences, Olana, Harbour House, 2020 Gulf Shore and 3300 Gulf Shore are being built in their place.

Is a per-unit buyout price what an owner received? No. Each figure here is the reported purchase price for the whole property divided by the number of homes that stood on it. It does not show how any building split the proceeds among its owners.

The land under a 1960s Miracle Mile condo can be worth very different amounts depending on which side of Gulf Shore Boulevard North it sits on and how much ground comes with each home. If you own in one of these older buildings or are weighing a purchase in one, The Beachfront Team can walk you through the sale history of your stretch of the Miracle Mile, building by building. Experience the Beachfront Difference: schedule a confidential consultation or start with a private valuation.

Experience the Beachfront Difference

The Beachfront Team delivers expert guidance, local insight, and personalized service for buyers and sellers throughout Naples’ most desirable coastal communities. From beachfront condominiums to luxury waterfront estates, we’re committed to helping you move with confidence and clarity.

Follow Us on Instagram